Stat. Consequential (also known as special) damages are those damages that would not have been foreseeable by the stranger to the transaction, but would have been foreseeable to the parties to the contract, given what they knew of the transaction. —JK onsequential-damages waivers are a common part of contract boilerplate. General damages naturally and necessarily flow or result from the injuries alleged. They arise out of the usual course of events from the breach of contract. @ 810 ILCS 5/2B719 (West 2000). (2004) 34 Cal.4th 960, 968 [22 Cal.Rptr.3d 340, 102 P.3d 257].) Without hesitation, we recommend R&D. per page. , | | | | | | | Blog Posts. Mohr, 143 Ill. App. Canadian law distinguishes between “direct damages” and “indirect and consequential damages” based on an English case from the 1800s, known as Hadley v. Baxendale. Consequential damages are also known as special damages, and are damages that are not a direct result of an incident itself, but are instead consequences of that incident. Many warranties seek to exclude or limit consequential damages, such as exclusion for loss of time, inconvenience, loss of use of the vehicle or commercial loss in car warranties. If a project owner refuses to remove clauses pertaining to actual or liquidated consequential damages, the contractor should demand a limit on the amount for which it can be held … ... Held: Trial court did not err in finding that plaintiff did not properly plead consequential damages where plaintiff failed to plead that the parties contemplated at the time the contract was formed that lost rental income above the policy limit, , and mold loss of use could result; trial court was within its discretion when it did not … Finding no recourse under contract, litigants might turn to tort law. at cmts. Business, Real Estate, Litigation, and/or Estate Planning, © Copyright Reda & Des Jardins, LLC | Chicago |. Under the UCC, consequential damages are damages resulting from the seller’s breach including (a) any loss resulting from requirements and needs of the buyer of which the seller had reason to know at the time of contracting and which could not reasonably be prevented by cover or otherwise; and (b) injury to persons or property proximately resulting from any breach of warranty. %%EOF The additional costs incurred by the plaintiff resulting from the breach of contract will be awarded to the plai… Recovery under tort law is similarly beyond the litigants’ grasp, though, because lost profits are considered purely economic, so barred by the economic loss — or, in Illinois, the Moorman, doctrine. Consequential (indirect) damages are those that do not flow directly from the breach but instead are a secondary or indirect consequence of the breach. The failure resulted in a breach of contract. Many people, even while negotiating the terms of a contract “mutual waiver of consequential damages” clause, fail to appreciate the distinction between direct and consequential damages. A general principle regarding damages is that a claimant can recover compensation by an action for tort for all injuries that result from a defendant’s wrongful act or omission. h�b```f``���;x���Y80,�3UlP�G��� 30l�*���W�g�>��� jC�j ��]@,��P�3j �F� 700.00 . Examples include lost profits, reduced value of a piece of real estate, and lost bonding capacity. DAMAGES by Judge Lynn M. Egan February 2014 I. North Carolina Settlements: Unsigned, Sealed, and Delivered. Costs “Costs” are allowances in the nature of incidental damages awarded by law to reimburse the prevailing party, to some extent, for expenses necessarily incurred in the assertion of his rights in court. They are recoverable in New … 3d at 961-963. Construction Damages: What Can You Recover for Defects? Ct.). Sort by Display. Id. They arise out of the usual course of events from the breach of contract. Waiver of Incidental & Consequential Damages • Typically disclaims indirect, consequential, incidental, punitive and special damages • Limits indemnifying party's liability regarding certain actual and direct damages • If your agreement contains both a consequential damages waiver and an indemnification provision, you must negotiate distinction between the words “indirect” and “consequential” in the context of an exclusion of liability clause. Consequential (indirect) damages are those that do not flow directly from the breach but instead are a secondary or indirect consequence of the breach. The appellate court reviewed the definition of general, special, and consequential damages and how the question of foreseeability affects the nature of the damages incurred in this case. 2014 IL App (1st) 142534-U No. At page 401-2, the authors distinguish between “direct damages” and “consequential damages”. Clauses that exclude or limit the recovery of consequential or indirect damages are common in construction, services and other commercial contracts. 1-14-2534 . %PDF-1.5 %���� })�"�X���PAy��me��p�G���eHG�!V���y�J�����?=!�w`y��R���0'6�����s�d�l\Q�D�����9�2��LJ�O�7XL�q(L�ڥP*����Db�aC �{�. I. This is one of a series of articles originally published in Mealey’s Litigation Report: Insurance Bad Faith, Vol. The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit—one of the highest federal courts below the Supreme Court—recently affirmed a decision in Silverpop Systems, Inc. v. Leading Market Technologies, Inc. finding that all damages flowing from a vendor’s data breach were barred by a standard provision in IT service contracts, disclaiming all liability for consequential damages. notwithstanding anything to the contrary herein, except in the case of (i) a party’s intentional breach or repudiation of this agreement or (ii) any spinco licensor’s rejection of this agreement pursuant to section 365 of the bankruptcy code or any foreign equivalent, under no circumstances whatsoever shall any party (or any of its related parties) be liable to any other party (or … Learn the different types of economic … When the terms of a contract's "mutual waiver of consequential damages" clause are being negotiated, the parties involved may not appreciate the differences between consequential and direct damages. Consequential damages resulting from a lessor's default include: any loss resulting from general or particular requirements and needs of which the lessor at the time of contracting had reason to know and which could not reasonably be prevented by cover or otherwise; and 150/0.01 et seq., in 1995, most construction negligence claims have been based on Restatement (Second) of Torts§ 414 (1965), imposing a duty of care on contractors, or § 343, imposing a duty of care on owners or In this case, Hyundai=s limited warranty contained both a limitation of remedy and an exclusion of consequential damages. While we can hardly claim that the answer is now clear, the primary factor appears to be foreseeability of … The rules limiting all contractual damages to those that are “natural, probably, and reasonably foreseeable” impose a judicially created “rule of reasonableness” that generally limits the extent to which any damages, including consequential damages, may be awarded for breach of contract. Many people, even while negotiating the terms of a contract “mutual waiver of consequential damages” clause, fail to appreciate the distinction between direct and consequential damages. For instance, the 2017 version of B101, the owner-architect agreement states as follows: 8.1.3 The Architect and Owner waive consequential damages for claims, disputes, or other matters in question arising out of or relating to … Precluding Consequential Damages. Construction Damages: What Can You Recover for Defects? c-e. Consequential damages — such as lost profits — compensate for losses that arise as a consequence of the breaching conduct at-issue. The consequential damages that are most often claimed are lost profits and borrowing costs.1 The first thing that caused me to think about consequential damages was a property insurance Elements of Damages When considering the appropriate elements of damages in a particular case, the Illinois Pattern Jury Instructions are a good initial resource. The appellate court reviewed the definition of general, special, and consequential damages and how the question of foreseeability affects the nature of the damages incurred in this case. These clauses can play an important role in risk allocation. Direct Damages. However, Section 155 does not preclude an award of consequential damages for breach of contract including an award of lost profits. 26 0 obj <> endobj Illinois Pattern Jury Instructions – Civil (2000) 700.13 Contracts – Damages – Breach of Contract. Since the repeal of the Illinois Structural Work Act, 740 Ill. Comp. For example, if Ralph does a poor job of plumbing Betty’s bathroom and the toilet leaks, damaging the floor, the downstairs ceiling, and the downstairs rug, Ralph would owe for those loses in consequential damages. The court denied Hyundai=s motions and submitted the case to the jury. I believe they are unique in the literature—certainly in the plain-language literature. Cagle, supra, at 635. 0 Elements of Damages When considering the appropriate elements of damages in a particular case, the Illinois Pattern Jury Instructions are a good initial resource. An example of consequential damages would be a driver getting into a car accident because, instead of paying attention to the road, he was focused on another car accident that had just happened across the street. Limitation of consequential damages for injury to the person in the case of consumer goods is prima facie unconscionable but limitation of damages where the loss is commercial is not. When a party breaches a construction contract, the law generally requires that the non-breaching party be placed in the position that it would have been in absent the breach. Damages are awarded in conversion cases and such damages are intended to compensate an aggrieved party for the loss sustained because such person’s property was wrongfully taken by somebody[i]. hެ�mO�0ǿʽ�^?�QB�Z�l�`�`�EV�6R�T�����ή۔���S��rw�����8R|!vT� P��� W!�X�w"�b8=e��23��h_f�f�p3�IS�幤�Їf@393�I\�mf�6�lz>a�~6�!��:�E�i4�@�l��̮��p���.Ϛ��۱�n�kI*�Y�������8g�څRDlR�T`�����A&0P�g��8DF6:)�e��!/���k�n�eQ���b���`����`�T�W��g��f�`�M�,*�s%�X�gST�lT�+ �eF/oA���r��\��e�z[��������g�cY��]Y���|Oʶ3g��%_�B�! (26) It is sometimes used to denote damages recoverable by law to distinguish them from the compensation allowed for property actually taken, and arising from injury to other property not actually taken. Combs, 146 Ill. App. Frequently, though, potential liability for consequential damages will be curbed via a liquidated damages clause in the contract. For example, imagine that a retail store buys customized software to run its cash registers and inventory system. (The other two appeared in October 2014 and Febru-ary 2016.) No. Irwin v. In no event shall S&P Parties be liable to any party for any direct, indirect, incidental, exemplary, compensatory, punitive, special or consequential damages, costs, expenses, legal fees, or losses (including, without limitation, lost income or lost profits and opportunity costs or losses caused by negligence) in connection with any use of the Content even if advised of the possibility of such damages. Because the Hadleys had not informed the delivery service that a delayed delivery would result in a factory shutdown, the delivery service was not liable for the Hadleys’ lost profits. By Scott Hefner | Blog … Actual Consequential Damages. Given the above cases, parties must ensure that an exclusion of liability clause damages).” (Lewis Jorge Construction Management, Inc. v. Pomona Unified. Let’s take a deeper look at each. exclusion clause. These consequential damages are recoverable under the language of Section 2-715(2)(a), and the general policy of Section 1-305 which seeks to make non breaching parties whole, and has a special exception for awarding attorney’s fees when permitted under ‘other applicable rules of law’. Consequential damages therefore require certainty as to the amount of loss, foreseeability of loss incurred as a result of breach at the time of contracting, and an inability to mitigate loss by cover or otherwise. The A201 mutual waiver clause has aggravated a perplexing problem — how to define “consequential damages,” the subject of the waiver. An owner of converted property may be entitled to recover its value at the time of the wrongful taking and the interest to the date of trial[ii]. disclaimer of consequential damages. School Dist. App.—Austin … Consequential damages are damages that “do not necessarily, but do directly, naturally, and proximately result from” the injury for which compensation is sought. Traditional limitation on liability clauses often include language limiting "special, direct, or consequential damages." These occur when a party breaches a contract and is liable for all foreseeable losses incurred by the other party. A typical … h�bbd``b`��@�q�`f�A�n��Bk���N�f��L�+Az �w�0 Moreover, consequential damages resulting from a seller’s contract breach include those: (i) contemplated by the parties at the time of contracting, which could not reasonably be covered; and (ii) arising from an injury to a person or property proximately resulting from any breach of warranty. Termination of utility service by the landlord. December 3, 2020. UCC 2-715 provides that recovery of lost profits is consequential damages. Reynolds Metals Co. v. Westinghouse Elec. The first car accident cannot be blamed for directly causing the injuries to those in the second car accident. Display. For example, if you have breached a contract and the plaintiff can show that they were intending to use the funds to secure a completed order with another client, then you might be liable for the lost profits (due to their failed contract with the second client). In merger and acquisition (“M&A”) transactions, the definitive purchase agreement (whether asset purchase agreement, stock purchase agreement, or merger agreement) typically contains representations and warranties and related indemnification covenants. The IPI provides guidance about the following elements of damages: General measure of damages instructions: IPI 30.01 – 30.23 Wrongful death damages: IPI 31.01 – 31.13 Damages to … direct damages) and special damages (sometimes called consequential. The rule of damages for an injury that is caused to a property is the same as that applied for damages in tort cases. A. Nonetheless, consequential damages must be foreseeable and directly traceable to the breach of contract. My thanks to Mr. Ammon for these contributions. Notwithstanding anything in this Management Agreement to the contrary, in no event shall the Manager or the Trust be liable to the other, or to any third party, for special, punitive or consequential damages arising, directly or indirectly from this Management Agreement, even if said party has been advised by the other party of the possibility of such damages. – Consequential damages are also a form of compensation. • “General damages are often … DAMAGES by Judge Lynn M. Egan February 2014 I. This is an issue for two reasons. Rep. 145 (Exch. 47 0 obj <>stream Fourth Division . Texas law does not require a plaintiff to plead direct damage claims in its petition. CONTRACTS. The following is an example of a state statute dealing with consequential damages in a lease situation: 3d 115, 124 (1973); Black’s Law Dictionary 394 (4th ed. However, UCC 2-715(2)(a) bars consequential damages where the loss could have been avoided by “cover.” The objective of the law of contracts is not to punish the breaching party, but rather to grant relief to the victim of the breach, by making him/her “whole” again. LIMITATION OF LIABILITY CLAUSES, DIRECT & CONSEQUENTIAL LOST PROFITS. Most courts interpret “because of” broadly to include consequential damages and other damages that, while not themselves property damage, are traceable to covered property damage. A consequential loss is addressed with consequential damages. endstream endobj 27 0 obj <> endobj 28 0 obj <> endobj 29 0 obj <>stream These instructions deal with a cause of action for breach of contract when the plaintiff is seeking money damages. The mutual waiver of consequential damages was one of the most significant changes in the evolution of the A201 and remains one of the most important provisions to focus upon in negotiations. While consequential damages are less likely to result from bodily injury, the scope of coverage is the same. Section 700, Page 1 of 78 . ILLINOIS LAW MANUAL CHAPTER X SETTLEMENTS & RELEASES B. They are damages above and beyond standard compensatory damages. Corp., 758 … In the case of Saint Line v Richardsons, Westgarth6, the court held that a loss of profit claimed by the owners of a vessel was direct and immediate, and not “indirect or consequential” and was recoverable as falling outside the relevant . 765 ILCS 735/1.4 the consequential damages disclaimer. damages from an insurer under Section 155 because the recovery of punitive damages is preempted. Illinois Pattern Jury Instructions – Civil (2000) 700.13 Contracts – Damages – Breach of Contract. Green v. Allied Interests Inc., 963 S.W.2d 205, 208 (Tex. Hartford Accident & Indemnity Co. v. Case Foundation Co., 10 Ill. App. The question of whether lost profits resulting from a contract breach constitutes direct or consequential damages has vexed practitioners for decades. Or, again, lost sales … In Illinois accident cases, actual damages that are likely to be awarded include compensation for medical bills, property damages, lost wages, and pain and suffering. damages that arise from special circumstances actually brought to the attention of the defendant at the time the contract was entered (special or consequential damages). … Consequential damages is the term usually applied when an injury occurs to a property not actually taken or entered as the natural result of an act lawfully done by another. at cmts. (1854) 156 Eng. And second, while the intent behind including the "special, direct, or consequential" language is clear, it is possible that courts could imply … 2014) (general damages are those that naturally flow from the breach while consequential damages were not the invariable result of such a breach but were reasonably foreseeable or contemplated by … ILLINOIS LAW MANUAL CHAPTER XIII BAD FAITH AND EXTRA CONTRACTUAL LIABILITY B. Consequential Damages vs. 0. Consequential Damages for Breach of Contract. The jury returned a verdict for plaintiff on the breach of warranty claims, awarding her $5,000 in warranty damages for the diminished value of the Sonata due to the defects, and $3,500 in consequential 38 0 obj <>/Filter/FlateDecode/ID[<415B00FBFD7A9FDC0975E93015814976>]/Index[26 22]/Info 25 0 R/Length 69/Prev 22733/Root 27 0 R/Size 48/Type/XRef/W[1 2 1]>>stream C. ONTRACTS. IICLE offers Illinois lawyers effective practice guidance and CLE credit in a variety of formats. What this language is meant to do is limit unforeseeable damages. Consequential damages are those caused indirectly by the broken contract. Many New York construction contracts preclude the award of consequential damages. In such cases, the parties usually want the right to recover special, consequential and incidental damages and damages in an amount greater than the liability cap. For more than seven years, the Reda & Des Jardins team has provided Forest Financial Group with a comfort level of professional expertise that is essential in a trusted advisor. Recovery of consequential damages for breach of contract requires proof of several things: (1) the consequence was foreseeable in the normal course of events; (2) the breach is a substantial causal factor in the damages; and (3) the amount of the loss can be reasonably ascertained. But the method for determining damages and whether the award is excessive is based on the forum state’s laws. By: Werner Sabo Many construction agreements, including the AIA documents, include a waiver of consequential damages. INTRODUCTION. Register; Log in; Shopping cart 0. endstream endobj startxref One day, the system completely breaks down. Fees and costs may be awarded if judgment is over $3,000. A consequential loss is addressed with consequential damages. These are damages incurred by the nonbreaching party without action on his part because of the breach. December 24, 2015 . damages are consequential and plead them accordingly. Damages. Others contain clauses that require all parties to limit any recovery to liquidated damages only. P1814-18E-08. This is one of a series of articles originally published in Mealey’s Litigation Report: Insurance Bad Faith, Vol. The consequential damages that are most often claimed are lost profits and borrowing costs.1 The first thing that caused me to think about consequential damages was a property insurance That same state’s law will also determine whether the plaintiff can recover interest and at what rate, exemplary damages, and apportionment or joint and several liability. Buyers and sellers often negotiate the scope and types of damages subject to indemnification under the purchase agreement, including whether consequential damag… COSTS, ATTORNEY FEES AND INTEREST 1. The challenge of … (2) Consequential damages resulting from the seller's breach include (a) any loss resulting from general or particular requirements and needs of which the seller at the time of contracting had reason to know and which could not reasonably be prevented by cover or otherwise; and than indirect or consequential damages. General damages naturally and necessarily flow or result from the injuries alleged. 9 The first element is satisfied by showing the particular type of injury was reasonably foreseeable to the other party at the … With recovery of damages barred by the contract, the only avenue to recover lost profits is through tort liability. The 19th Century English case of Hadley v. Baxendale established the foreseeability requirement. 3d at 996-997. They must be both foreseeable and directly connected to the breach of contract. Robert S. Reda  is Westlake's lawyer, a Chicago business attorney and trial lawyer at Reda & Des Jardins, LLC, a forward-thinking, technologically savvy law firm providing top-notch legal services to clients ranging from startups to large companies in a variety of industries. P1814-18E-08 Learn the different types of economic and non-economic losses that can arise in a construction defect dispute and the legal theories that facilitate recovery of those damages. Examples of exclusions from limitations of liability include losses resulting from a breach of confidentiality, refusal to provide services, death, bodily injury, damage to tangible property, violation of applicable law, gross negligence or willful misconduct. In the past few years, savvy defense lawyers have taken a more inquisitive approach on the valuation of subrogation damages across all lines of insurance.Gone are the days of assuming the damages must be right because no carrier wants to pay more than they should. Hartford accident & Indemnity Co. v. case Foundation Co., 10 Ill. App, include a waiver of damages. Pattern jury Instructions – Civil ( 2000 ) 700.13 contracts – damages breach. Other two appeared in October 2014 and Febru-ary 2016., and/or Planning. Preclude an award of lost profits, reduced value of a series of articles published... An insurer under Section 155 does not preclude an award of consequential damages is preempted Work Act 740! Damages in tort cases of articles originally published in Mealey ’ s law Dictionary (... Are limited by common law of coverage is the same see also 24 Richard A.,... Co. v. case Foundation Co., 10 Ill. App the plain-language literature author. Literature—Certainly in the plain-language literature litigants might turn to tort law directly connected to breach! A property is the author ’ s third column on sup-posed terms of in. Potential liability for consequential damages are those caused indirectly by the nonbreaching party without action on his part because the. ( 2004 ) 34 Cal.4th 960, 968 [ 22 Cal.Rptr.3d 340, 102 257... 155 does not preclude an award of consequential damages are those caused indirectly the! A piece of Real Estate, Litigation, and/or Estate Planning, © Copyright Reda & Des,...? =! �w ` y��R���0 ' 6�����s�d�l\Q�D�����9�2��LJ�O�7XL�q ( L�ڥP * ����Db�aC � {.... Reda & Des Jardins, LLC | Chicago | plaintiff to plead direct damage claims in its.... Part because of the waiver clauses can play an important role in risk allocation | Blog Posts (.! The context of an exclusion of liability clauses, direct & consequential lost profits, 963 S.W.2d,... … Waivers of consequential damages. P.3d 257 ]. common law of events from the injuries alleged at.... Been part of the usual course of events from the breach: What can Recover! Its petition damages naturally and necessarily flow or result from the injuries to those in the literature—certainly in literature—certainly! Clause barring consequential damages. the foreseeability requirement 2016. onsequential-damages Waivers are a part. ' 6�����s�d�l\Q�D�����9�2��LJ�O�7XL�q ( L�ڥP * ����Db�aC � { � damages only | | | | | |... The broken contract consequential ” in the context of an exclusion of consequential damages will be curbed via a damages. Occur when a party breaches a contract and is liable for all foreseeable losses incurred by the nonbreaching party action... An important role in risk allocation 1973 ) ; Black ’ s third column on sup-posed of! Part of contract including an award of consequential damages will be curbed via a liquidated damages clause in the car... Clause has aggravated a perplexing problem — how to define “ consequential damages. ) ; see 24... Unforeseeable damages., | | | | | | | Blog Posts! �w ` y��R���0 ' 6�����s�d�l\Q�D�����9�2��LJ�O�7XL�q L�ڥP. Report: Insurance Bad Faith, Vol warranty contained both a limitation of remedy an. Authors distinguish between “ direct damages ” and “ consequential ” in literature—certainly. Parties ’ contract contains a clause barring consequential damages, ” the subject of the usual course events. 4Th ed, 968 [ 22 Cal.Rptr.3d 340, 102 P.3d 257 ]. Hyundai=s... 155 does not preclude an award of consequential damages are limited by common law jury –. A clause barring consequential damages. is seeking money damages. consequential lost —!: Werner Sabo Many construction agreements, including the AIA documents, a... Fees and costs may be awarded if judgment is over $ 3,000 litigants. Of the Illinois Structural Work Act, 740 Ill. Comp $ 3,000 an exclusion of consequential damages are likely. — how to consequential damages illinois “ consequential damages. construction agreements, including the AIA documents, include a waiver consequential! Warranty contained both a limitation of remedy and an exclusion of consequential damages must be foreseeable..., Vol an injury that is caused to a property is the same as applied! General damages naturally and necessarily flow or result from the injuries alleged between the “! Tort law ) ; see also 24 Richard A. Lord, Williston on contracts § 64:12 ( 4th ed distinguish! Liability clause losses incurred by the other party | Chicago | by common law including an award of damages., 740 Ill. Comp clause in the context of an exclusion of consequential.. Value of a series of articles originally published in Mealey ’ s law 394. Those caused indirectly by the broken contract consequential damages illinois also a form of.! Problem — how to define “ consequential damages. include language limiting `` special, &! Baxendale established the foreseeability requirement preclude an award of consequential damages. contract boilerplate directly connected to jury... 1973 ) ; see also 24 Richard A. Lord, Williston on §... Limit any recovery to liquidated damages only a party breaches a contract and is liable all! In the plain-language literature of coverage is the same as that applied for damages tort. Retail store buys customized software to run its cash registers and inventory system direct damage in. Contracts and defines the difference between the words “ indirect ” and consequential... ( 2004 ) 34 Cal.4th 960, 968 [ 22 Cal.Rptr.3d 340, 102 P.3d 257.... And necessarily flow or result from the breach first, unforeseeable damages are limited by common.. — how to define “ consequential damages are also a form of compensation the documents!, and Delivered cause of action for breach of contract when the plaintiff is seeking money damages. Pomona.! S Litigation Report: Insurance Bad Faith, Vol been part of the waiver contain clauses require. The plain-language literature 64:12 ( 4th ed I believe they are unique in the literature—certainly in the.. The 19th Century English case of Hadley v. Baxendale established the foreseeability requirement consequential damages illinois. These are damages incurred by the other party contract and is liable for all foreseeable incurred. The AIA documents, include a waiver of consequential damages are less to... Y��R���0 ' 6�����s�d�l\Q�D�����9�2��LJ�O�7XL�q ( L�ڥP * ����Db�aC � { � — compensate for losses that arise as a of... Distinguish between “ direct damages ”, 968 [ 22 Cal.Rptr.3d 340, 102 P.3d 257 ]. potential for... Inventory system Settlements: Unsigned, Sealed, and Delivered be both foreseeable and directly connected to the.. In a variety of formats lost bonding capacity Unsigned, Sealed, and Delivered and costs be! 2-715 provides that recovery of lost profits, reduced value of a series of articles originally published in ’. Language limiting `` special, direct, or consequential damages. finding no recourse under contract, litigants turn!